diff --git a/client/web/src/cody/management/api/client.ts b/client/web/src/cody/management/api/client.ts
index 4c5f6f122b748..df63de0e59d6a 100644
--- a/client/web/src/cody/management/api/client.ts
+++ b/client/web/src/cody/management/api/client.ts
@@ -70,7 +70,7 @@ export module Client {
         return { method: 'POST', urlSuffix: '/team/current/invites', requestBody }
     }
 
-    export function resendInvite(inviteId: string): Call<Response> {
+    export function resendInvite(inviteId: string): Call<unknown> {
         return { method: 'POST', urlSuffix: `/team/current/invites/${inviteId}/resend` }
     }
 
diff --git a/client/web/src/cody/management/api/react-query/invites.ts b/client/web/src/cody/management/api/react-query/invites.ts
index 3a259b7741308..b3d0d869a1f02 100644
--- a/client/web/src/cody/management/api/react-query/invites.ts
+++ b/client/web/src/cody/management/api/react-query/invites.ts
@@ -44,10 +44,10 @@ export const useSendInvite = (): UseMutationResult<TeamInvite, Error, CreateTeam
     })
 }
 
-export const useResendInvite = (): UseMutationResult<Response, Error, { inviteId: string }> => {
+export const useResendInvite = (): UseMutationResult<unknown, Error, { inviteId: string }> => {
     const queryClient = useQueryClient()
     return useMutation({
-        mutationFn: async ({ inviteId }) => callCodyProApi(Client.resendInvite(inviteId)),
+        mutationFn: async ({ inviteId }) => (await callCodyProApi(Client.resendInvite(inviteId))).json(),
         onSuccess: () => queryClient.invalidateQueries({ queryKey: queryKeys.invites.teamInvites() }),
     })
 }
diff --git a/client/web/src/cody/team/TeamMemberList.tsx b/client/web/src/cody/team/TeamMemberList.tsx
index e672d6b70431b..5501685d24b30 100644
--- a/client/web/src/cody/team/TeamMemberList.tsx
+++ b/client/web/src/cody/team/TeamMemberList.tsx
@@ -102,16 +102,16 @@ export const TeamMemberList: FunctionComponent<TeamMemberListProps> = ({
                 setLoading(true)
                 telemetryRecorder.recordEvent('cody.team.resendInvite', 'click', { privateMetadata: { teamId } })
 
-                const response = await resendInviteMutation.mutateAsync.call(undefined, { inviteId })
-                if (!response.ok) {
+                try {
+                    await resendInviteMutation.mutateAsync.call(undefined, { inviteId })
+                    setLoading(false)
+                    setActionResult({ message: 'Invite resent.', isError: false })
+                } catch (error) {
                     setLoading(false)
                     setActionResult({
-                        message: `We couldn't resend the invite (${response.status}). Please try again later.`,
+                        message: `We couldn't resend the invite (${error}). Please try again later.`,
                         isError: true,
                     })
-                } else {
-                    setLoading(false)
-                    setActionResult({ message: 'Invite resent.', isError: false })
                 }
             }