add linecaps (GLMakie, CairoMakie) #2536

ffreyer · 2022-12-30T10:16:17Z

Description

This pr aims to add linecaps to lines! and linesegments! in GLMakie.

Current prototype (second commit) should render caps for lines (triangular, rectangular or circular depending on the values in the shader.)

(Debug) Example for round line caps:

GLMakie.closeall(); display(GLMakie.Screen(), lines([1, 2, NaN, 4, 5], linewidth = 50))

TODO

closes #1119, #2205

Also related: #871

Type of change

New feature (non-breaking change which adds functionality)

Checklist

Added an entry in NEWS.md (for new features and breaking changes)
Added or changed relevant sections in the documentation
~~Added unit tests for new algorithms, conversion methods, etc.~~
Added reference image tests for new plotting functions, recipes, visual options, etc.

ffreyer · 2022-12-30T10:18:39Z

GLMakie/assets/shader/lines.frag

@@ -10,6 +10,7 @@ in vec4 f_color;
 in vec2 f_uv;
 in float f_thickness;
 flat in uvec2 f_id;
+flat in int f_type; // TODO bad for performance


Given the comment in the scatter shader

Makie.jl/GLMakie/assets/shader/distance_shape.frag

Line 26 in 4dab995

uniform int shape; // shape is a uniform for now. Making them a in && using them for control flow is expected to kill performance

I assume we should find a way around this?

Did some benchmarking with

let GLMakie.closeall() ps = [2 * rand(Point2f) .- 1 for _ in 1:2000] function myrenderloop(screen) yield() GLMakie.GLFW.SwapInterval(0) GLMakie.pollevents(screen) GLMakie.render_frame(screen) GLMakie.GLFW.SwapBuffers(GLMakie.to_native(screen)) yield() @time for _ in 1:10_000 GLMakie.pollevents(screen) GLMakie.render_frame(screen) GLMakie.GLFW.SwapBuffers(GLMakie.to_native(screen)) end while GLMakie.isopen(screen) && !screen.stop_renderloop GLMakie.pollevents(screen) sleep(0.1) yield() end return end scene = Scene() linesegments!(scene, ps, linewidth = 10) screen = GLMakie.Screen(renderloop = myrenderloop) display(screen, scene) end

I get the same ~5% CI got for this branch vs master.

I tried hacking together a two pass version which does the old lines in the first pass and caps in the second pass. This way we can swap out the flat in int f_type for uniform int linecap and uniform int render_pass. This ends up being about 10% slower than master though, doing both passes. Doing just the line pass is 3-4% slower.

I think that's ok for linecaps! Can we optionally disable it and get the 5% back for high perf use cases? We could also think about having a different recipe for that though 🤷 I think the default should make good lines, and performance should be the special case!

Reducing the number of options in the fragment shader (5e206a9) helped a bit ... I think. I'm never sure with gpu benchmarking. When I tested it I got a bunch of benchmarks that were ~2% slower than master and then a bunch up to 5% slower 🤷

I ran them again without background processes and I'm getting ~2% now (812ff3f)

MakieBot · 2022-12-30T10:43:52Z

Compile Times benchmark

Note, that these numbers may fluctuate on the CI servers, so take them with a grain of salt. All benchmark results are based on the mean time and negative percent mean faster than the base branch. Note, that GLMakie + WGLMakie run on an emulated GPU, so the runtime benchmark is much slower. Results are from running:

using_time = @ctime using Backend
# Compile time
create_time = @ctime fig = scatter(1:4; color=1:4, colormap=:turbo, markersize=20, visible=true)
display_time = @ctime Makie.colorbuffer(display(fig))
# Runtime
create_time = @benchmark fig = scatter(1:4; color=1:4, colormap=:turbo, markersize=20, visible=true)
display_time = @benchmark Makie.colorbuffer(display(fig))

	using	create	display	create	display
GLMakie	28.71s (28.59, 29.16) 0.21+-	16.43s (16.22, 16.96) 0.25+-	15.28s (15.13, 15.71) 0.20+-	9.50ms (9.37, 9.57) 0.07+-	119.97ms (118.67, 121.79) 1.15+-
master	29.00s (28.70, 29.28) 0.23+-	16.31s (16.09, 16.65) 0.19+-	15.18s (15.07, 15.41) 0.15+-	9.29ms (9.19, 9.37) 0.07+-	112.24ms (110.95, 113.13) 0.88+-
evaluation	-1.01%, -0.29s faster ✓ (-1.30d, 0.03p, 0.22std)	+0.74%, 0.12s invariant (0.56d, 0.32p, 0.22std)	+0.65%, 0.1s invariant (0.56d, 0.32p, 0.17std)	+2.17%, 0.21ms slower X (2.89d, 0.00p, 0.07std)	+6.44%, 7.73ms slower❌ (7.55d, 0.00p, 1.01std)
CairoMakie	25.32s (25.21, 25.60) 0.14+-	16.59s (16.36, 17.01) 0.24+-	2.65s (2.60, 2.72) 0.04+-	9.30ms (9.14, 9.49) 0.14+-	4.17ms (4.10, 4.28) 0.07+-
master	25.62s (25.41, 25.88) 0.16+-	16.50s (16.20, 16.83) 0.22+-	2.56s (2.50, 2.60) 0.04+-	9.04ms (8.96, 9.14) 0.06+-	4.10ms (3.92, 4.19) 0.09+-
evaluation	-1.19%, -0.3s faster ✓ (-2.00d, 0.00p, 0.15std)	+0.51%, 0.08s invariant (0.38d, 0.50p, 0.23std)	+3.42%, 0.09s slower X (2.31d, 0.00p, 0.04std)	+2.87%, 0.27ms slower X (2.47d, 0.00p, 0.10std)	+1.87%, 0.08ms invariant (0.98d, 0.09p, 0.08std)
WGLMakie	36.40s (36.24, 36.61) 0.12+-	19.96s (19.78, 20.30) 0.18+-	21.24s (20.83, 21.71) 0.27+-	12.74ms (12.23, 13.22) 0.41+-	1.71s (1.65, 1.77) 0.05+-
master	36.76s (36.58, 37.03) 0.16+-	19.88s (19.73, 20.08) 0.11+-	21.13s (20.91, 21.51) 0.22+-	12.75ms (12.29, 13.16) 0.31+-	1.73s (1.66, 1.80) 0.05+-
evaluation	-0.97%, -0.35s faster ✓ (-2.46d, 0.00p, 0.14std)	+0.39%, 0.08s invariant (0.51d, 0.36p, 0.15std)	+0.54%, 0.11s invariant (0.47d, 0.40p, 0.24std)	-0.06%, -0.01ms invariant (-0.02d, 0.97p, 0.36std)	-1.24%, -0.02s invariant (-0.44d, 0.42p, 0.05std)

ffreyer · 2022-12-31T16:21:44Z

GLMakie/src/drawing_primitives.jl

@@ -269,7 +270,7 @@ function draw_atomic(screen::Screen, scene::Scene, @nospecialize(x::Lines))
 data[:pattern] = ls
 else
 linewidth = gl_attributes[:thickness]
- data[:pattern] = ls .* (to_value(linewidth) * 0.25)
+ data[:pattern] = ls * _mean(to_value(linewidth))


I took this as somewhat of a shortcut for now, because linestyle needs some cleanup anyway.

Example with variable linewidth:

GLMakie.closeall() widths = [57.37044620677474, 27.847264587380923, 56.663525479541775, 47.302310563997985, 56.36164168328704, 43.014590186214285, 58.832167079498525, 27.208798997411307, 17.12575358453462, 45.95171757911098, 26.771344098755126, 35.85649823581235, 53.08232474276624, 27.217846025535966, 43.98443255191129, 37.389819316502695, 18.07005596531466, 59.569472267387056, 50.919270815270814, 36.74914882840677, 53.08834081120422, 45.44455789568474, 40.147375157549135, 22.166337026901253, 50.53203686576642, 15.238811525483367, 12.780634172815944, 12.980713770063876, 28.175981476856755, 37.542112019663485] ys = [0.3672275443344566, 0.13769475910008522, 0.22445059716611304, 0.5883310148108587, 0.7893622240334566, 0.3129809823712394, 0.953606981656488, 0.2770419071274035, 0.3048558242752848, 0.6782285082882588, 0.5447836889282002, 0.19905515156197973, 0.19770277191975638, 0.537590947032379, 0.28027667604204765, 0.8287252657638743, 0.9336781225747905, 0.1371941303349402, 0.5973028266375866, 0.3561025405662749, 0.43500848119792546, 0.36410392908891054, 0.9117308440489152, 0.8008057243055526, 0.2349037873519133, 0.21294938231466431, 0.8334978136186971, 0.5097696792342837, 0.21488349759400982, 0.3434422610208452] fig = Figure() ax = Axis(fig[1, 1]) # p = linesegments!(ax, ys, linewidth = widths./10, linecap = 4, linecap_length = widths./10, color = :red) # p = linesegments!(ax, ys, linewidth = widths./10, linecap = 4, linecap_length = widths./10, linestyle = :dot) p = lines!(ax, ys, linewidth = widths./10, linecap = 0, linecap_length = widths, color = :red) p = lines!(ax, ys, linewidth = widths./10, linecap = 0, linecap_length = widths, linestyle = :dash) screen = display(GLMakie.Screen(), fig)

produces

and pixel perfect results with constant linewidth (tested explicitly for linewidth = 50 on a straight line with lines and linesegments looks the same).

There is however some artifacting with :dash that got more frequent but isn't new. From master:

Oh right, I also changed the scaling with linewidth in lines! (not here but in the shader) which makes :dash shorter notably at large linestyles. It's now 3lw on, 3lw off like the pattern requests. master has weird scaling, maybe quadratic? For linewidth 50, it seems to be about 40.1lw on, 40.1lw off. For linewidth 10 about 10.5lw on 10.5lw off

lines([0, 0], linewidth = 50, linestyle = :dash)

ffreyer · 2022-12-31T18:24:48Z

Refimg test I added for linecaps:

This shows (nothing, :square, :round), default for lines, then (nothing, :square, :round) for linesegments. New default is :square like in PyPlot.jl

github-actions · 2022-12-31T22:23:08Z

Missing reference images

Found 1 new images without existing references.
Upload new reference images before merging this PR.

github-actions · 2023-01-01T11:27:13Z

Missing reference images

Found 1 new images without existing references.
Upload new reference images before merging this PR.

github-actions · 2023-01-17T16:59:44Z

Missing reference images

Found 1 new images without existing references.
Upload new reference images before merging this PR.

ffreyer · 2023-01-18T17:34:19Z

https://discourse.julialang.org/t/y-axis-in-cairomakie-jl-not-vertical/93165 made me realize that a pixel offset attribute for lines is probably less niche than I first thought, so I'm reworking linecap_length into a more general length_offset.

@jkrumbiegel This would allow you to nudge the start and endpoints of a line around by some number of pixel. So for an axis you could make ticks start 1 frame thickness later, and shorten/lengthen some of the frame lines by one thickness to avoid overlap. Or for 2d arrows you could use this to stop the line before the marker.

because while offsets work line caps and joints don't

ffreyer · 2023-01-18T19:51:11Z

I added length_offset for lines and linesegments across the board with this refimg:

WGLMakie support is there but the refimg test doesn't match because WGLMakie can't handle linecaps and doesn't have line joins

github-actions · 2023-01-18T20:09:05Z

Missing reference images

Found 2 new images without existing references.
Upload new reference images before merging this PR.

github-actions · 2023-01-18T22:09:26Z

Missing reference images

Found 2 new images without existing references.
Upload new reference images before merging this PR.

github-actions · 2023-01-18T23:01:39Z

Missing reference images

Found 2 new images without existing references.
Upload new reference images before merging this PR.

ffreyer · 2023-01-24T09:23:58Z

GLMakie display: +10.76%, 19.38ms slower ❌ (4.54d, 0.00p, 4.17std)

This seems to be mostly display time, not render time. Running render-N-frames check returns (1.7% min, 8.5% max, 1.8% mean, 1.3% median) more time spend on rendering here. (I'm now running 30 timings at 1k frames and filter spikes > 20% mean.) I guess this spike in display time isn't really that surprising with me adding another buffer to upload.

Code

```julia let for _ in 1:30 GLMakie.closeall() ps = [2 * rand(Point2f) .- 1 for _ in 1:2000]

    function myrenderloop(screen)
        yield()
        GLMakie.GLFW.SwapInterval(0)
        GLMakie.pollevents(screen)
        GLMakie.render_frame(screen)
        GLMakie.GLFW.SwapBuffers(GLMakie.to_native(screen))
        yield()

        @time for _ in 1:1_000
            GLMakie.pollevents(screen)
            GLMakie.render_frame(screen)
            GLMakie.GLFW.SwapBuffers(GLMakie.to_native(screen))
        end

        while GLMakie.isopen(screen) && !screen.stop_renderloop
            GLMakie.pollevents(screen)
            sleep(0.1)
            yield()
        end

        return
    end

    scene = Scene()
    linesegments!(scene, ps, linewidth = 10, linecap = nothing)
    screen = GLMakie.Screen(renderloop = myrenderloop)
    display(screen, scene)
    GC.gc()
    sleep(1)
end

end

using Statistics

function remove_spikes(ts, threshold = 0.2)
m = mean(ts)
return filter(t -> abs(t - m) < threshold * m, ts)
end

</details>

github-actions · 2023-01-29T20:51:21Z

Missing reference images

Found 2 new images without existing references.
Upload new reference images before merging this PR.

ffreyer · 2023-01-30T13:26:26Z

In Cairo linecaps are applied to dashes as well. It's set up to take space away from the "off" part of dashes. I.e. (with pattern being the vector of float we generate from a linestyle)

  cap              cap      cap
 |---|------------|---|    |---|------
     ^            ^            ^
 pattern[1]   pattern[2]   pattern[3]

I've adjusted the linestyle lengths so that caps take space from the "on" part of a dash/dot instead of the "off" part. So it's not:

      cap      cap              cap
     |---|----|---|            |---|--
     ^            ^            ^
 pattern[1]   pattern[2]   pattern[3]

github-actions · 2023-01-30T13:33:02Z

Missing reference images

Found 2 new images without existing references.
Upload new reference images before merging this PR.

ffreyer · 2023-02-25T12:53:05Z

This will interfere heavily with #2666 and I think it's better to redo this than #2666 so I'm making this a draft for now

SimonDanisch · 2023-03-31T10:22:14Z

What do we do with this pr after #2666 got merged?

ffreyer · 2023-03-31T10:36:23Z

Probably kill it and restart it. Most of this would need to be redone either way.

I've also been thinking it would be good to match Cairo linecaps in GLMakie. They put them on each dash/dot, this pr only did lin start/end.

SimonDanisch · 2023-03-31T10:39:33Z

Ok, makes sense! I'll close it then ;)

ffreyer added 2 commits December 30, 2022 10:52

prototype linecaps in shader

fe0043f

fix triangle

5c14b08

ffreyer commented Dec 30, 2022

View reviewed changes

ffreyer added 10 commits December 30, 2022 13:13

fix antialiasing & add uniforms

1035f9a

add line shortening and mirrored triangle

2868301

only shorter discontinous lines

ac54023

fix printing

58238c4

make linewidth and linecap_length per vertex

21c260d

add linecaps to linesegments

41a200f

fix cut off triangles

2103da7

minor cleanup

8af7d28

improve triangle fix

fe26ed7

get linestyles working

df4cc82

ffreyer commented Dec 31, 2022

View reviewed changes

ffreyer added 6 commits December 31, 2022 18:06

add linecap attribute

0ed7fd3

add refimg test

0bcc438

update NEWS

4b3f232

add linecap to CairoMakie

344d5ba

update NEWS

a0e8004

exclude linecap test from WGLMakie

d571ae9

ffreyer added 2 commits December 31, 2022 22:45

minor cleanup

afc879a

Merge branch 'master' into ff/linecaps

1503d8f

ffreyer changed the title ~~add linecaps to GLMakie~~ add linecaps (GLMakie, CairoMakie) Dec 31, 2022

ffreyer marked this pull request as ready for review December 31, 2022 21:58

fix test failure

6ac6bf7

simplify fragment shader (drop triangle caps)

5e206a9

ffreyer requested a review from SimonDanisch January 17, 2023 16:32

ffreyer added 5 commits January 18, 2023 20:46

rework linecap_length into more general length_offset

ef78de7

add reference test for offsets

bbf3445

add length_offset to CairoMakie

06afc32

add offsets to WGLMakie and exclude test

29e9c1d

because while offsets work line caps and joints don't

add entry for length_offset

22e42a4

remove experimental stuff

6ada0f6

fix screen to clip transformation

e9a853b

Merge branch 'master' into ff/linecaps

835b582

Merge branch 'master' into ff/linecaps

f99ccaf

adjust linestyle spacing with linecaps

add06f8

ffreyer mentioned this pull request Feb 10, 2023

[GLMakie] Cleanup linestyles #2666

Merged

7 tasks

ffreyer marked this pull request as draft February 25, 2023 12:51

SimonDanisch closed this Mar 31, 2023

This was referenced May 24, 2024

allow for different line widths in lines #1541

Closed

linewidth for linesegments in CairoMakie #2205

Closed

Provide feedback

Saved searches

Use saved searches to filter your results more quickly

add linecaps (GLMakie, CairoMakie) #2536

add linecaps (GLMakie, CairoMakie) #2536

ffreyer commented Dec 30, 2022 •

edited

Loading

ffreyer Dec 30, 2022

ffreyer Dec 31, 2022 •

edited

Loading

SimonDanisch Jan 1, 2023

ffreyer Jan 2, 2023

ffreyer Jan 3, 2023

MakieBot commented Dec 30, 2022 •

edited

Loading

ffreyer Dec 31, 2022

ffreyer Dec 31, 2022

ffreyer commented Dec 31, 2022

github-actions bot commented Dec 31, 2022

github-actions bot commented Jan 1, 2023

github-actions bot commented Jan 17, 2023

ffreyer commented Jan 18, 2023

ffreyer commented Jan 18, 2023

github-actions bot commented Jan 18, 2023

github-actions bot commented Jan 18, 2023

github-actions bot commented Jan 18, 2023

ffreyer commented Jan 24, 2023

github-actions bot commented Jan 29, 2023

ffreyer commented Jan 30, 2023 •

edited

Loading

github-actions bot commented Jan 30, 2023

ffreyer commented Feb 25, 2023

SimonDanisch commented Mar 31, 2023

ffreyer commented Mar 31, 2023

SimonDanisch commented Mar 31, 2023

add linecaps (GLMakie, CairoMakie) #2536

add linecaps (GLMakie, CairoMakie) #2536

Conversation

ffreyer commented Dec 30, 2022 • edited Loading

Description

TODO

Type of change

Checklist

ffreyer Dec 30, 2022

Choose a reason for hiding this comment

ffreyer Dec 31, 2022 • edited Loading

Choose a reason for hiding this comment

SimonDanisch Jan 1, 2023

Choose a reason for hiding this comment

ffreyer Jan 2, 2023

Choose a reason for hiding this comment

ffreyer Jan 3, 2023

Choose a reason for hiding this comment

MakieBot commented Dec 30, 2022 • edited Loading

Compile Times benchmark

ffreyer Dec 31, 2022

Choose a reason for hiding this comment

ffreyer Dec 31, 2022

Choose a reason for hiding this comment

ffreyer commented Dec 31, 2022

github-actions bot commented Dec 31, 2022

Missing reference images

github-actions bot commented Jan 1, 2023

Missing reference images

github-actions bot commented Jan 17, 2023

Missing reference images

ffreyer commented Jan 18, 2023

ffreyer commented Jan 18, 2023

github-actions bot commented Jan 18, 2023

Missing reference images

github-actions bot commented Jan 18, 2023

Missing reference images

github-actions bot commented Jan 18, 2023

Missing reference images

ffreyer commented Jan 24, 2023

github-actions bot commented Jan 29, 2023

Missing reference images

ffreyer commented Jan 30, 2023 • edited Loading

github-actions bot commented Jan 30, 2023

Missing reference images

ffreyer commented Feb 25, 2023

SimonDanisch commented Mar 31, 2023

ffreyer commented Mar 31, 2023

SimonDanisch commented Mar 31, 2023

ffreyer commented Dec 30, 2022 •

edited

Loading

ffreyer Dec 31, 2022 •

edited

Loading

MakieBot commented Dec 30, 2022 •

edited

Loading

ffreyer commented Jan 30, 2023 •

edited

Loading