[BUILD] Alternative way of exporting symbols (generating .def file)

[meastp]

The current way of generating opentelemetry_cpp.def requires manually adding every symbol that is to be exported to opentelemetry_cpp.src. For symbols that differ based on compilation options (e.g. 64bit / 32bit) they have to be added individually and guarded with a macro.

This is an alternative approach that provides some convenience (=less maintenance):

• UPDATE: the dumpbin.exe tool is located with Visual Studio's vswhere (I currently select the first match, but vswhere searches can easily be more specifix, e.g. only x64 architecture binaries)
• all available symbols in the libraries (.lib files) are extracted with the dumpbin tool
• an input file input.src contains regex-statements (also macros (e.g. WITH_OTLP_HTTP etc)
• input.src is preprocessed (as opentelemetry_cpp.src is today) into input.txt
• a powershell script generates a .def file with matching symbols from input.txt

This is a proof-of-concept. Currently, I have tried to duplicate the symbols exported today (except, all overloads are also available as they match the regex, so all 9 overloads of TracerProviderFactory::Create will be exported, for example, which is useful).

One could for example simplify the input/regex part to export all symbols containing "opentelemetry" (and perhaps be able to provide regex for symbols that should be excluded, if there are any?)

I'm not familiar enough with all symbols available to tell what approach is better, although if we could eliminate the input file and just export all symbols matching "opentelemetry", it would require minimal future maintenance.

I'll keep this as a draft for now, very interested in your input :)

For significant contributions please make sure you have completed the following items:

• CHANGELOG.md updated for non-trivial changes
• Tests are covered by building and running the examples
• No changes in public API

[codecov]

Codecov Report

All modified and coverable lines are covered by tests ✅

❗ No coverage uploaded for pull request base (main@8f88553). Click here to learn what that means.

Additional details and impacted files

@@           Coverage Diff           @@
##             main    #2476   +/-   ##
=======================================
  Coverage        ?   87.09%           
=======================================
  Files           ?      200           
  Lines           ?     6103           
  Branches        ?        0           
=======================================
  Hits            ?     5315           
  Misses          ?      788           
  Partials        ?        0           

[marcalff]

Thanks for this tooling.

This is a huge improvement to the existing build IMO:

• The idea to use a regexp to export a "loosely" defined symbol, without the full prototype specification, is a big help, especially for maintainers that do not have a windows machine locally (like me)
• Exporting all XXX::Create() methods at once instead of listing all flavors with different prototypes helps. I assume that if somehow we need to be more specific, there is always the possibility to provide less selective regexp with the full prototype then, if needed, so this is not a blocking feature.
• opentelemetry-cpp should not export all symbols named opentelemetry::xyz, so it is very desirable to list explicitly which class/methods are part of the public API, instead of exporting everything
• This will work very well with different ABIs, like 32/64 bit flavors, and will also work very well with different STL, because "nostd::unique_ptr" can mean different things and can become different types affecting the final symbol name, when compiling with different STL levels (nostd::X can be anything like nostd::X, std::X, abseil::X, ...)

Suggestions:

Is it possible to simplify the input.src file further, so that:

External\s+\|\s+(\?Create@OStreamSpanExporterFactory@trace@exporter@v1@opentelemetry[^\s]*)\s+\((.*)\)$

is replaced by just:

Create@OStreamSpanExporterFactory@trace@exporter@v1@opentelemetry

with the makefile scripts adding the regexp magic sauce.

Also, please add a licence and copyright line in new files, to fix the CI break for make_def.ps1

Waiting on @open-telemetry/cpp-maintainers for more comments.

Looks good.

[meastp]

@marcalff thanks - I have tried to do what you suggested, moving part of the regex into the powershell-script (and added the copyright/license line).

I also made this PR ready for review (no longer a draft)

[malkia]

Not sure if helpful, but bazel implements symbol parsing (to find external) symbols using this ad-hoc parser - https:/bazelbuild/bazel/tree/master/third_party/def_parser - It has worked for me, but it doesn't work with /LTCGO (e.g. whole program optimization, because the .obj files are just AST trees of sorts then)

[meastp]

@malkia That's interesting - thanks for the tip :) However, I think I'd keep using dumpbin which is the official tooling. We would have to keep the functionality to filter which symbols to keep/export anyway, so switching to def_parser wouldn't simplify much, unfortunately.

[ThomsonTan]

Thanks @meastp for the PR. Could you please help compare the list of exported function w/o this PR? Trying to understand how much more symbols could be exported with the regexp.

[meastp]

@ThomsonTan the regexes basically match functions by name with namespace, so the only additional exported symbols would be overloads of the functions that aren't exported today but propably should be, right? :)

[ThomsonTan]

@meastp can you please take a look at the format of the CMakeLists.txt?

[meastp]

@ThomsonTan done :)

[ThomsonTan]

Thanks for the contribution, LGTM.

[marcalff]

LGTM, thanks for the tooling.

[lalitb]

Thanks. This will help in maintaining the symbols better way.