Surround with try/catch reformats document

[clankill3r]

This behaviour is more then a year old, but it often bugs me so hard that I thought it's time for a report.
It just happened again on a really large file where I noticed it way too late.

Ok, when using try/catch the whole document gets reformatted:

before:

after:

Environment

• Operating System: OSX
• JDK version: OpenJDK 11
• Visual Studio Code version: latest
• Java extension version: latest

[fbricon]

Can you check if it is the same behavior in Eclipse? If yes, then that would need to be fixed in upstream JDT

[ronakg]

I can confirm this. It doesn't happen on Eclipse. Tried with Version: 2020-06 (4.16.0) Build id: 20200615-1200.

[clankill3r]

I just noticed, when you type `var` and use the "Change type of '...' to '...'" then this reformats happens as well. It is also really aggressive with comments.

[ronakg]

Any updates on this issue? I noticed that this happens for any source action in VSCode. Today I tried to automatically add getter setter for a particular field and it reformatted the whole class.

However, the source action and formatting are happening in 2 separate stages. I was able to undo the formatting and keep the source action result.

[ronakg]

Wondering if this is being looked into.