Peer review by Smita

[SmitaG1995]

• Documentation:
  • title and abstract of the project (max 300 words) Good abstract
  • includes instructions on how to run the notebook No instructions found in Read me. Can you provide the instruction in read me instead of in the notebook
  • includes the required packages in an environment.yml file It would be better if you rename the file to environment.yml
  • includes a brief explanation of the reason each package/library was used Yes
  • includes rich documentation using Markdown (equations, tables, links, images or videos) Yes nice description
  • is reproducible, i.e., someone else should be able to redo the steps I got an error 'No module scipy found' Maybe something wrong with environment file?
• Input/Output:
  • uses pandas to read large data sets or numpy to load data from text files Yes
  • uses pandas to save to disk the processed or generated data Yes
• Scientific computing/data processing:
  • performs numerical operations (numpy, scipy, pandas) or manipulates, groups, and aggregates a data set (pandas) Yes
• Data visualization:
  • includes at least one composite plot (inset or multiple panels) I couldn't make plots because of the scipy error
  • produces publication ready quality figures (see here for an editorial guide on Graphical Excellence): I couldn't make plots because of the scipy error
• Version control, sharing, and archiving:
  • is archived in a repository with a digital object identifier (DOI) Yes